Scooby-Doo is one of the biggest and most recognizable franchises in cartoon history. Several generations of audiences fell in love with the talking dog and his mystery-solving friends. That’s why it was especially exciting for the animated icon to be adapted into live action movies in the early 2000s.

Both films are absolutely fantastic, and they represent and celebrate the source material well. They’re both a lot of fun and have the perfect cast for the fan-favorite characters. However, it is worth noting that the second movie, Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed, is a much better adaptation of the classic cartoon than its predecessor.

This doesn’t mean that the original 2002 live action movie is bad by any means. It’s hilarious, exciting, and full of heart. It’s just that, despite the characters being spot-on and it fits the spooky vibe, the movie lacks quite a few elements that make Scooby-Doo what it is.

Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed serves as a much better adaptation of the original series. There’s an actual mystery afoot. Despite all of the real monsters wreaking havoc, there’s still a criminal wearing a menacing disguise that needs to be unmasked. The members of Mystery Inc. spend much of the film searching for clues to solve the case, and there’s an actual list of potential suspects, each of which are believable.

This is unlike the first one where they say they’re solving a mystery and looking for clues, but it’s not really happening. They gang discover that the monsters are real, battle foes, run for their lives, and then it’s suddenly revealed to be Scrappy-Doo as the main perpetrator of it all. None of the clues would have led to him, and he wasn’t even on the suspect list. Once it’s discovered there are real monsters capturing people, there’s not a lot of “searching for clues” throughout. The second movie corrects this and goes above and beyond doing so.

Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed found a way to go bigger and raise the stakes by using real monsters (and ones based on the costumes from the cartoons – further celebrating the source material) all while still having a true mystery with actual clues and a suspect list at its center. It really felt like a more grand version of the TV series, which a lot of fans should appreciate.

Read Next: Should Real Monsters Have a Place in ‘Scooby-Doo’?